Charting the era of sustainable competitiveness: Legal perspectives on small farmers under the simplified Common Agricultural Policy
Authors: Mirta Alessandrini
ABSTRACT
This contribution examines the legal and structural position of small farmers under the ‘simplified’ Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) following the adoption of Regulation (EU) 2025/2649 (‘Omnibus III’). It situates the reform within the Commission’s 2025 simplification and competitiveness agenda and the broader shift towards a paradigm of ‘sustainable competitiveness’, offering both a doctrinal and normative assessment of its implications. The analysis first outlines the legal definition and structural positioning of small farmers under the 2023–2027 CAP, highlighting persistent asymmetries in income distribution, administrative capacity, and access to innovation. It then examines the Omnibus III amendments across conditionality, direct payments, business development measures, and risk management instruments, with particular attention to their differentiated effects on small-scale holdings. In a second step, the reform is assessed through the six pillars of sustainable competitiveness, including natural capital, social capital, resource efficiency, governance, intellectual capital, and economic sustainability. This framework serves as an interpretive lens to evaluate not only the stated objective of simplification but also the outcomes that small farmers can realistically achieve under this new paradigm. While the Omnibus III reform delivers some administrative relief and modest improvements in income support, it also relaxes environmental baselines for small farm beneficiaries, leaves social and knowledge related dimensions largely unaddressed, and reinforces predominantly top-down governance structures. The article argues that the simplified CAP risks exemplifying, once again, a form of ‘shallow post-exceptionalism’: a rhetorical and procedural adjustment that preserves underlying distributive and institutional patterns without significant structural change.
Keywords:

